How Medical Liens and Health Insurance Affect Your Car Accident Settlement

Unresolved liens can create problems that drag on long after a settlement is reached. Hospitals may turn unpaid bills over to collections, Medicare can add interest to outstanding balances, and ERISA plans can even take repayment disputes into federal court.

---

Medical liens and reimbursement reduce settlements after a car accident case. A settlement check rarely goes straight into the injured person’s pocket because health insurers, hospitals, and government programs like Medicare can require repayment from that money before anything is released. Repayment claims can shrink the final recovery, and the net amount may end up very different from the gross settlement.

Liens vs. Subrogation: What They Really Mean

A medical lien is when a hospital, doctor, or even an ambulance service places a legal claim against the settlement to cover the unpaid bills. Subrogation is when an insurance company asks for repayment after covering medical costs tied to the accident. In the end, they both take money out of the final payout.

Who Can Claim Part of the Settlement

Hospitals and doctors use liens if medical bills haven’t been paid, or if they went ahead and provided treatment on the promise that the provider would be reimbursed later. Health insurers usually have language in their policies that allows them to take money from a settlement once it comes through. If they were part of the process, government programs like Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, and FEHBA can also demand repayment, and their claims will typically come first. Some employer health plans fall under ERISA, and if the plan is self-funded, it can override state laws that might normally block subrogation.

How Settlement Money Gets Distributed

Settlement funds don’t move straight into someone’s pocket, instead they first go into a trust account. From there, payouts usually start with the attorney’s share, medical providers or government programs, and go from there. For example, the case is closed and the settlement funds are ready in the trust account. Payouts could be made in this order:

1. Attorney fees and case costs, including expenses for experts, records, and filing
2. Liens and insurance reimbursements, with government programs like Medicare usually getting paid first
3. Any remaining balance released to the client

Many accident victims are caught off guard when the final check from their settlement is smaller than the settlement amount they anticipated.

Legal Doctrines That Can Reduce Liens

There are two legal principles that can sometimes reduce how much lienholders collect from a settlement. They don’t apply in every case, but when they do, they can minimize the reductions in the final payout to victims.

• Made Whole Doctrine: An insurer is only supposed to recover money if the injured person has been fully compensated for all losses. In practice, many insurance policies include fine print that waives this protection, which means the insurer can still demand repayment.
• Common Fund Doctrine: If an attorney’s work is what produced the settlement, lienholders may have to share in the cost by covering part of the attorney’s fee before they collect their share.

Using made whole or common fund doctrines usually comes down to paperwork and persistence. An experienced attorney can review policy language for waivers, demand accurate ledgers from lienholders, and press for reductions tied to attorney fees or hardship. Without that push, lienholders will just default to collecting the full amount they ask for.

Strategies to Protect a Settlement

Repayment demands don’t have to be accepted at face value, and part of the job of a skilled car accident attorney is to challenge them. There are a few strategies that can be used to cut back the amounts lienholders are expecting to collect:

Making a significant difference on any liens or other settlement deductions usually comes from combining a few strategies. For example, a billing audit cuts the claimed balance, then a hardship package pushes it lower, and finally the common fund doctrine reduces it again by the attorney’s fee percentage. Stacking a few strategies together is how a good attorney can turn an inflated lien into something manageable.

Hiring an Experienced Attorney to Protect a Settlement

Unresolved liens can create problems that drag on long after a settlement is reached. Hospitals may turn unpaid bills over to collections, Medicare can add interest to outstanding balances, and ERISA plans can even take repayment disputes into federal court.

Lien resolution is sometimes not discussed in free consultations with lawyers, but it is its own process, separate from negotiating with the at-fault driver’s insurer. Attorneys can spend weeks or months trading letters with lien departments, correcting billing codes, and calculating reductions in line with federal and state rules. Without an attorney in the mix, a victim may think their case is over when the check arrives, only to start getting repayment demands or collection calls months later. If you’ve been in a car accident, do yourself a favor and avoid all of that by hiring the right attorney, from the start.